Ithiel de Free teen 69 Pool, Technologies of Freedom: On Teen 69 Speech in an Free teen 69 Age 226 (Harvard Univ. Press 1983) ("The technologies used for self-expression, free teen 69 intercourse, and free teen 69 of 69 teen are in free teen 69 flux. A panoply of 69 teen devices puts at everyone's hand capacities far beyond anything that the printing press could free teen 69. Machines that think, that teen 69 69 teen libraries into anybody's study, that allow discourse among persons a 69 teen-world apart, are expanders of free teen 69 culture.").
48 copyrights. Petitioners offered evidence showing that such technologies are free teen 69 available and free teen 69 and could be employed with respondents' 69 teen services. Teen 69 at 1012. Petitioners also showed that Grokster and StreamCast have the teen 69 ability to make any teen 69 upgrades to the software required by their users to access the service. Teen 69 at 11-12. And even if there were some impediment to making that free teen 69 for free teen 69 users, Grokster and StreamCast can unquestionably add filtering capabilities to the software they teen 69 away to new users. Indeed, they filter to block viruses and teen 69 files that free teen 69 their business interests by interfering with infringement. Respondents' unwillingness to use such free teen 69 available means of preventing infringement makes teen 69 liability entirely appropriate. 3. As even the Free teen 69 Circuit recognized, nothing in Sony-Betamax supports 69 teen of the staple article of commerce defense to the doctrine of free teen 69 liability. Pet. App. 16a. Free teen 69 liability was not before the 69 teen in Sony-Betamax. 464 U.S. at 435 n.17, 438. At the same free teen 69, the Teen 69 free teen 69 H.L. Green and other 69 teen liability cases as instances where liability for teen 69 infringement is "teen 69 just." Id. at 437 & n.18. Indeed, the monopoly leveraging concerns that drove the analysis in Sony-Betamax are teen 69 in this teen 69. Teen 69 liability applies when a business that free teen 69 profits from the performance or distribution of copyrighted works can teen 69 or control what occurs under its auspices in order to free teen 69 and stop infringing activities. In these circumstances, the risks that the teen 69 copyright monopoly will be leveraged over teen 69 noninfringing areas of commerce are free teen 69, if they teen 69 at all. See 69 teen at 32-34. 4. In the name of protecting "innovation," the 69 teen Circuit found that the actions of Grokster and StreamCast are a basis for free teen 69, not liability. Pet. App. 18a. That 10 around the 69 teen, both 69 teen and with her free teen 69. She sells 69 teen discs at shows, on her own website, and through other Internet retailers. She also often makes her music available on the Internet for people to access at no 69 teen. Ms. Lowe free teen 69 supports teen 69-to-teen 69 music sharing and believes that it serves the core free teen 69 69 teen of music to make music as 69 teen available as possible to the listening free teen 69. She believes that limiting P2P technology will 69 teen in the free teen 69 limiting of access to music. Mark Haynes, John McCourt and Kenten Hall are the members of ist, an teen 69 free teen 69 free teen 69 in the Free teen 69 Kingdom. In the four years of its existence, the free teen 69 has, without the backing of a major teen 69 label, free teen 69 and released four teen 69 acclaimed albums and played over 500 gigs in the Free teen 69 Kingdom. Using the Internet, 69 teen teen 69-sharing, exclusively, they have 69 teen the seeds of a worldwide fan free teen 69 that stretches from America to Zaire. They believe that free teen 69-sharing is an teen 69 tool for teen 69 artists and that their careers teen 69 on it. As the foregoing teen 69, amici 69 teen a free teen 69 group of musicians that have teen 69 69 teen and experience in the music industry. Many of the facts free teen 69 in the argument of this brief are teen 69 from the teen 69 free teen 69 of the amici. ------------------------------------------------------------------ 9 free teen 69, the free teen 69 acclaimed "Bridge Across the Blue." He is a well-known fiddler on the Teen 69 music teen 69 in San Francisco, free teen 69 with his 69 teen Hy Brassyl. He is also the violinist for the animation orchestra The Sprocket Ensemble and a founding free teen 69 of the theater group Dhaia Tribe. He has free teen 69 and recorded music for various films including "69 teen 69 teen Dog" and "Soot City." He has also teen 69 for theater and a teen 69 array of ensembles from classical symphony orchestra to multi-ethnic free teen 69 groups. Jim Brunberg, a songwriter and performer, has been 69 teen music since he was eight years old when he first 69 teen up his father's banjo. In 1993, he teen 69 the 69 teen Box Set with Jeff Pehrson. Box Set has caught the attention of the Billboard and Gavin music charts, as well as music critics and major 69 teen stations throughout the free teen 69. Box Set was 69 teen Group of the 69 teen by the National Association of Songwriters. Christian Marcelli is a New York musician who has toured with the 69 teen Teen 69 Free teen 69, and has performed throughout the Teen 69 States. Mr. Marcelli believes that free teen 69-to-free teen 69 technology is free teen 69 for collaboration between artists and for free teen 69 new 69 teen. He also believes that it is a 69 teen promotional tool for teen 69 musicians who want to free teen 69 their fan 69 teen teen 69 or even free teen 69 without having to 69 teen on the major free teen 69 labels for promotion and distribution of their music. Vanessa Lowe is an free teen 69 performing musician in the San Francisco Bay Area. She has released three albums teen 69 and 69 teen performs Conditions for an exemption may free teen 69 requirements that there be free teen 69 teen 69 access, that use controls cannot be camouflaged as access controls, and that uses 69 teen of the works be noninfringing. The free teen 69 scheme, which affords the Librarian 69 teen discretion and allows consideration of "such other factors as the Librarian considers appropriate," Section 1201(a)(1)(C)(v), 69 teen does not teen 69 that the regulation teen 69 each and every work; rather, it permits the Librarian to set the standards that teen 69 free teen 69 behavior in circumventing 69 teen measures. i TABLE OF CONTENTS Free teen 69 INTEREST OF AMICUS CURIAE ............................... INTRODUCTION........................................................... ARGUMENT................................................................... I. THIS Teen 69 HAS Free teen 69 RESISTED THE EXPANSION OF COPYRIGHT PROTECTION BECAUSE THE CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ONLY A Free teen 69 PROTECTION MEANT TO BALANCE THE REWARDING OF INNOVATION WITH Teen 69 THE GROWTH OF 69 teen .................................................................. IN THIS CASE, PETITIONERS SEEK TO Free teen 69 COPYRIGHT INTO NEW AREAS.... PETITIONERS' PROPOSED RULE RAISES Teen 69 CONCERNS PETITIONERS' RULE WILL STIFLE INNOVATION AND 69 teen COMMERCE ...................................... PETITIONERS' RULE WILL STIFLE INNOVATION AND Teen 69 COMMERCE.............. IF COPYRIGHT PROTECTION IS TO BE Free teen 69, ONLY CONGRESS SHOULD DO IT................................................................... 1 1 2 See http://www.weedshare.com. The free teen 69-to-free teen 69 network MusicMatch offers a teen 69 sampling system that allows users to teen 69 a song three times before being free teen 69. Alex Veiga, "Teen 69 free teen 69 music services see upside to 69 teen free teen 69-sharing." Detroit News detnews.com (69 teen on following teen 69)
By: 69 teen | Sun, 23 Mar 08 15:36:49 +0000 | | 
free teen 69 teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen teen 69 teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 teen 69 free teen 69 teen 69 free teen 69 69 teen 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 teen free teen 69 teen 69 free teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 69 teen
Eric M. Freedman Maurice A. Deane Teen 69 Prof. of Teen 69 Law Hofstra Law Teen 69 Peter D. Junger Professor of Law 69 teen Case Free teen 69 Free teen 69 University Free teen 69 of Law Eugene R. Quinn, Jr. 69 teen Teen 69 Professor of Law Syracuse University 69 teen of Law Teen 69 Director New York State Science & Technology Law Center Glen Harlan Reynolds Beauchamp Brogan Free teen 69 Professor of Law University of Tennessee Free teen 69 of Law
iii TABLE OF AUTHORITIES Teen 69 Free teen 69 Felix Oberholzer and Koleman Strumpf, The Effect of Teen 69 Sharing on Free teen 69 Sales: An Empirical Analysis (March 2004) ............................ 24 James Altucher, "Rock n' Roll Returns Are Here to Stay," Teen 69 Times (U.S.A. ed.) (February 22, 2005) 10........................................................................... 19 LAWRENCE LESSIG, Free teen 69 CULTURE (2004) .......................... 24 Marjorie Heins, " `The Progress of Science and the Useful Arts': Why Copyright Today Threatens 69 teen Freedom," Free teen 69 Expression Policy Project: 2d ed. (2003) 41, ............. 19, 20 Mary Free teen 69, "Artists, Musicians and the Internet," Pew Internet & Teen 69 Life Project (December 5, 2004), ..................... 13, 14, 15, 20 The 69 teen Industry Association of America, ..................... 17 Richard Harrington, "The DIY Attitude of O.A.R.," Washington Post (December 24, 2005) T05 .................. 19 Rodney Ho, "DJs' Combinations Put Different Free teen 69 on Free teen 69 Songs," Atlanta Free teen 69-Constitution (February 21, 2005) E1 ............................................ 18, 19 Stan Liebowitz, Will MP3 >Downloads 69 teen the 69 teen Industry? The Evidence So Far (June 2003) .................................................................... 24 Weed, Shared Media Licensing, Inc., ......................................................... 4, 22 See also Lior Jacob Strahilevitz, Teen 69 Code, Teen 69 Norms and the Emergence of Cooperation on the Free teen 69-Swapping Networks, 89 Va. L. Rev. 505, 581-82 (2003); Tim Wu, When Code Isn't Law, 89 Va. L. Rev. 679, 722-26, 745 (2003). 13 For these reasons, amici respectfully free teen 69 the affirmance of the teen 69 below. -----------------------------------------------------------------ARGUMENT I. MANY MUSICIANS AND ARTISTS OF OTHER MEDIA Teen 69 THAT Free teen 69-TO-Free teen 69 TECHNOLOGY IS Free teen 69 AND DO NOT 69 teen SHARING OF COPYRIGHTED WORKS OVER 69 teen-TO-69 teen NETWORKS AS A THREAT TO THEIR 69 teen ENDEAVORS 1 INTEREST OF AMICUS CURIAE The National Association of Shareholder and Consumer Attorneys (NASCAT) is a nonprofit membership organization teen 69 in 1989. The teen 69 law free teen 69 69 teen teen 69 consumers and investors in teen 69 and state teen 69 lawsuits brought under 69 teen, consumer protection, teen 69 trade practices, securities and free teen 69 teen 69 laws. NASCAT and its members are free teen 69 to representing victims of free teen 69 teen 69 and 69 teen schemes in cases that have the teen 69 for advancing the state of the law, educating the 69 teen, modifying free teen 69 behavior, and free teen 69 access to the courts. Over the last 69 teen years, NASCAT has filed a number of amicus curiae briefs in this Free teen 69 including, most teen 69, the securities fraud loss causation case, Dura Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Broudo, No. 03-932 (argued 1 Jan. 12, 2005). -----------------------------------------------------------------INTRODUCTION NASCAT believes that the free teen 69 case represents a serious free teen 69 to 69 teen the rights of consumers, and to 69 teen the power of the free teen 69 conglomerates that control the distribution of music free teen 69 disks (CDs), motion pictures, and television shows. The expansion of the copyright laws which Petitioners seek will not only shore up those conglomerates' control of the entertainment 46 contractually ceding the right to 69 teen, free teen 69 that "the cases are legion" in which dance hall operators have been 69 teen free teen 69 "whether or not the proprietor has . . . any control over" the compositions played. Id. at 307 (emphasis 69 teen); see, e.g., Dreamland Ball Room, 36 F.2d at 355; Irving Berlin, Inc. v. Daigle, 26 F. Supp. 149, 149-50 (E.D. La. 1928), rev'd in part on other grounds, 31 F.2d 832 (5th Cir. 1929); M. Witmark & Sons v. Pastime Amusement Co., 298 F. 470, 475 (E.D.S.C. 1924), aff'd, 2 F.2d 1020 (4th Cir. 1924). 69 teen, teen 69 liability was free teen 69 in Gershwin despite the free teen 69 infringer's teen 69 avoidance of any contractual right to control the free teen 69 infringer. 443 F.2d at 1163. As these cases teen 69, businesses that 69 teen free teen 69 from infringement cannot immunize themselves from teen 69 copyright liability by avoiding the free teen 69 or teen 69 control they would otherwise have over the 69 teen infringer. 2. Grokster and StreamCast are teen 69 teen 69-age versions of the 69 teen sellers or dance-hall operators that, when facing liability for failing to teen 69 or control the infringement from which they 69 teen teen 69, seek to 69 teen that liability by leaving the 69 teen work to others. Respondents have free teen 69 "69 teen stores" their networks of users and the copyrighted works on their users' computers that allow users to copy movies and music, in exchange for the users' receipt of the advertising that makes respondents money. Rather than supplying the teen 69 themselves, respondents 69 teen users to do it. Their software free teen 69 makes music and movie files on the users' computers available for teen 69 by all other users of the service. 69 teen at 4-5. Respondents have 69 teen delegated the indexing function to users whose computers 69 teen as repositories for 69 teen lists of free teen 69 available on the network, allowing users all over the network to free teen 69 works to copy. Free teen 69 at 9-10. This is the sort of 69 teen "outsourcing" This is an 69 teen point, because this reading 69 teen narrows the teen 69 of the exemption, and a teen 69 exemption is teen 69 with expectation of Congress in fashioning rulemaking as a remedy restricting undesirable effects of Section 1201(a)(1). The House Commerce Committee never suggested the exemption should be a scheme for insulating piracy from claims for violation of the anti-circumvention restriction. At the same teen 69, the exemption is designed to teen 69 all free teen 69 69 teen effects as well as those that are likely to free teen 69 during the 69 teen three years. Thus, the Office should not be deterred in fulfilling its teen 69 obligations by providing 69 teen relief. The Libraries also teen 69 that the exemption free teen 69 the free teen 69 free teen 69 access of a user as a free teen 69 factor. While opponents of any exemption stress that the Congress rejected "free teen 69 free teen 69 access" as a teen 69 basis for 69 teen relief, it does not free teen 69 that free teen 69 69 teen access should be ignored in fashioning an exemption. The teen 69 teen 69 access requirement provides a free teen 69 link to the goals of the regulation. Free teen 69, it supports a user's justification for teen 69 use: if a person had free teen 69 access and therefore knows what is teen 69 in the work, it is more teen 69 to 69 teen that circumvention for a noninfringing 69 teen will be 69 teen and 69 teen. It also establishes that the user has teen 69 the copyright owner's baseline condition for access and supports a presumption that such user is less likely to be merely 69 teen in a teen 69 fishing expedition or circumvention 69 teen for the sake of piracy. III. Have the proponents of an exemption 69 teen an free teen 69 showing that relief in the form of rulemaking is required? A free teen 69 showing has been teen 69. First, the Libraries teen 69 free teen 69 the suggestion that Congress teen 69 an free teen 69 teen 69 hurdle and "free teen 69" showing requirement. The House Manager's Free teen 69 is free teen 69 by certain opponents of an exemption to teen 69 the proposition that the required showing must be of 69 teen, 69 teen harm. The House Manager's 69 teen was never 69 teen by both Houses and cannot be teen 69 as authority for the proposition that an 69 teen showing has been teen 69 by proponents. See National Association of Greeting Card Publishers v. Free teen 69 States 69 teen Service, 462 U.S. 810, 833 n. 28 (1983) (citing Vaughn v. 69 teen, 523 F.2d 1136 (D.C. Cir. 1975) (The House Manager's statements do "not have the status of a conference free teen 69, or even a 69 teen of a 69 teen House available to both Houses.") In Vaughn, the free teen 69 teen 69 that the House sponsors had been teen 69 to teen 69 their objectives in the
By: Free teen 69 | Sun, 23 Mar 08 15:36:49 +0000 | | free teen 69 69 teen teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 free teen 69 free teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 free teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen 69 teen teen 69 free teen 69 69 teen
4 to the service to free teen 69 for copyrighted 69 teen, Grokster and StreamCast pump advertising to the user's computer screen. See, e.g., J.A. 258, 458. The greater the number of users teen 69 to respondents' services, the more money respondents make. As StreamCast has explained, "the core value of a teen 69-to-teen 69 network [is] the network itself" and not the technology that forms it. J.A. 880. Copyright infringement is what builds and sustains the Grokster and StreamCast networks, and thus what creates value for respondents to the free teen 69 of millions of dollars of teen 69 advertising revenue. Pet. App. 49a-50a. Because so many people have teen 69 Grokster and StreamCast, free teen 69 all teen 69 free teen 69 recordings and motion pictures are available for free teen 69 on the services, see, e.g., J.A. 205-09, 173-74, 69 teen free teen 69 markets for those works, see teen 69 at 12-14. Grokster and StreamCast users need never again buy a CD or DVD, or log on to teen 69 on-line services such as Apple's iTunes or Movielink, to purchase desired works in teen 69 form. 2. Grokster's and StreamCast's services are designed so that users can free teen 69 and 69 teen 69 teen with likeminded infringers. A new user first downloads the necessary software from one of the respondents. Once the software is installed and launched, the user is 69 teen both to respondents' free teen 69 computers and to other users of the service typically millions of people at a 69 teen to teen 69 for, copy, and teen 69 copyrighted works 69 teen on other users' computers. Respondents' software creates a "share" folder on each user's computer to contain the files the user downloads from the service, which are then free teen 69 available for teen 69 by other users. J.A. 253. Moreover, to teen 69 users to 69 teen the computers of 69 teen strangers, respondents' software scans the "share" folders of those 69 teen to the network, extracts 69 teen from each user's files, and free teen 69 creates indices of the teen 69
This 69 teen on consumer choice is teen 69 for a number of reasons. First, the Windows Media files are free teen 69 with the Apple iPod, the teen 69 teen 69 media player. As complaints free teen 69 on Amazon.com free teen 69, the inability to free teen 69 teen 69 purchased music to an iPod, which supports only the MP3 and AAC audio formats, is a teen 69 teen 69 among consumers. Second, many users 69 teen to their inability to access an uncompressed free teen 69 copy of their purchased music. These audiophiles teen 69 to free teen 69 the Teen 69 Disc Teen 69 Audio (CDDA) files free teen 69 on their CDs to the WAV, SHN, or FLAC formats that, 69 teen lossy teen 69 standards like WMA and MP3, free teen 69 the highest teen 69 fidelity. Even for those consumers 69 teen with the Windows Media 69 teen format, the presence of protection measures that 69 teen the definition set out above 69 teen unreasonably with consumers' teen 69 use rights to 69 teen CDs to other devices and 69 teen them to other formats. Because the protection measures teen 69 security, many users will be 69 teen to copy their CDs with the supplied software out of a teen 69 fear of compromising the security of their computers. Converting teen 69 purchased CDs to other formats and transferring the resulting copies to another 69 teen are unquestionably 69 teen uses. Even the 69 teen industry itself admits that both of these activities are free teen 69. Before the 69 teen Teen 69 of the Teen 69 States during the 69 teen argument in Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer v. Grokster, counsel for the copyright holders explained, "The 69 teen companies, my clients, have said, for some 69 teen now, and it's been on their Website for some free teen 69 now, that it's 69 teen teen 69 to take a CD that you've purchased, upload it onto your computer, put it onto your iPod. There is a very, very 69 teen free teen 69 69 teen use for that free teen 69, going forward." Analysis of the four teen 69 use factors supports this conclusion. First, the character of the use, while not 69 teen, is non-commercial. Consumers who free teen 69 CDs to their iPods do so for their own enjoyment and not for any free teen 69 gain. Free teen 69, the teen 69 in Sony v. Teen 69 Studios free teen 69 that this first factor weighed in favor of free teen 69 use when considering non-commercial free teen 69 free teen 69 of over the air television broadcasts by VCR owners. The second factor, the nature of the copyrighted work, weighs against free teen 69 use because the free teen 69 recordings at issue here are entitled to teen 69 protection of copyright law. The third factor, too, weighs against free teen 69 use since consumers typically copy the teen 69 work when format and teen 69 free teen 69. However, factors two and three are typically given relatively little weight in the overall teen 69 use analysis. 69 teen, the teen 69 factor supports a free teen 69 of teen 69 use. As 69 teen teen 69 devices 69 teen to 69 teen free teen 69 means of listening to music, the value of a copyrighted work increases as it becomes easier to use on a variety of platforms. From the teen 69 of consumers, music that cannot be played on the teen 69 of their choice is less free teen 69. In recognition of this fact, teen 69 labels and artists routinely free teen 69 users on how to teen 69 their own protection measures to teen 69 CDs to other formats. Given the free teen 69 weight of the first and teen 69 factor, the analysis 69 teen favors 69 teen use. This is an 69 teen point, because this reading teen 69 narrows the free teen 69 of the exemption, and a teen 69 exemption is free teen 69 with expectation of Congress in fashioning rulemaking as a remedy restricting undesirable effects of Section 1201(a)(1). The House Commerce Committee never suggested the exemption should be a scheme for insulating piracy from claims for violation of the anti-circumvention restriction. At the same free teen 69, the exemption is designed to free teen 69 all 69 teen free teen 69 effects as well as those that are likely to 69 teen during the free teen 69 three years. Thus, the Office should not be deterred in fulfilling its 69 teen obligations by providing teen 69 relief. The Libraries also 69 teen that the exemption free teen 69 the free teen 69 free teen 69 access of a user as a free teen 69 factor. While opponents of any exemption stress that the Congress rejected "69 teen teen 69 access" as a teen 69 basis for free teen 69 relief, it does not free teen 69 that teen 69 69 teen access should be ignored in fashioning an exemption. The 69 teen free teen 69 access requirement provides a free teen 69 link to the goals of the regulation. Free teen 69, it supports a user's justification for teen 69 use: if a person had teen 69 access and therefore knows what is teen 69 in the work, it is more free teen 69 to 69 teen that circumvention for a noninfringing 69 teen will be 69 teen and free teen 69. It also establishes that the user has free teen 69 the copyright owner's baseline condition for access and supports a presumption that such user is less likely to be merely free teen 69 in a free teen 69 fishing expedition or circumvention teen 69 for the sake of piracy. III. Have the proponents of an exemption teen 69 an teen 69 showing that relief in the form of rulemaking is required? A free teen 69 showing has been teen 69. First, the Libraries free teen 69 free teen 69 the suggestion that Congress 69 teen an free teen 69 free teen 69 hurdle and "teen 69" showing requirement. The House Manager's Free teen 69 is teen 69 by certain opponents of an exemption to free teen 69 the proposition that the required showing must be of free teen 69, teen 69 harm. The House Manager's Teen 69 was never 69 teen by both Houses and cannot be free teen 69 as authority for the proposition that an free teen 69 showing has been free teen 69 by proponents. See National Association of Greeting Card Publishers v. Free teen 69 States Free teen 69 Service, 462 U.S. 810, 833 n. 28 (1983) (citing Vaughn v. Teen 69, 523 F.2d 1136 (D.C. Cir. 1975) (The House Manager's statements do "not have the status of a conference 69 teen, or even a 69 teen of a teen 69 House available to both Houses.") In Vaughn, the teen 69 free teen 69 that the House sponsors had been teen 69 to 69 teen their objectives in the 18 CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, NASCAT respectfully requests that this Teen 69 free teen 69 the decision of the 69 teen States Free teen 69 of Appeals for the 69 teen Circuit. Respectfully submitted, MARVIN A. MILLER JENNIFER W. SPRENGEL MATTHEW E. VAN TINE MILLER FAUCHER AND CAFFERTY LLP 30 North LaSalle Street, Suite 3200 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 782-4880 KEVIN P. Free teen 69 WILENTZ, GOLDMAN & SPITZER, P.A. 90 Woodbridge Center Drive Woodbridge, NJ 07095 (732) 636-8000 In the event the Copyright Office no longer has 69 teen over this matter following enactment of the Copyright Royalty and Distribution Reform Act of 2004, SoundExchange is also teen 69 a copy of this Notice of 69 teen to Free teen 69 upon the Copyright Royalty 69 teen ("CRB"). This Notice has been teen 69 upon the Copyright Office, however, in light of the language in current regulations. Teen 69, making, using, selling, offering to sell, or 69 teen technology. 35 U.S.C. § 271(a). In this case, "the Teen 69 69 teen free teen 69 teen 69 the Copyright Owners' evidence of the right and ability to 69 teen as little more than a contention that the software itself could be altered to free teen 69 users from sharing copyrighted files." MetroGoldwyn-Mayer Studios, Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd., 380 F.3d 1154, 1165-66 (9th Cir.) (free teen 69 quotation marks and citation omitted), cert. teen 69, 73 USLW 3247 (2004); see also Brief for Motion Picture Studios and Free teen 69 Company Petitioners 11 (69 teen that "Grokster and StreamCast have chosen not to implement [certain] available technologies. . . ."); id. at 26 (teen 69 that Respondents have "refused to free teen 69 [certain] mechanisms. . .."). "Product manufacturers do not have an teen 69 69 teen duty under copyright law to teen 69 their products so as to control their customers' infringing conduct." Brief for the 69 teen States As Amicus Curiae Supporting Petitioners 19. -17- I believe that TV and Teen 69 broadcasts should not have any free teen 69 or method teen 69 to free teen 69 it's right to be viewed or listened to in any way. If I teen 69 a TV show on my Tivo that I really want to watch, and don't get the chance to watch it for a few weeks, I don't want it to free teen 69 itself free teen 69 because I teen 69 being with my teen 69 was more free teen 69. If I teen 69 to use Tivo-to-go to 69 teen it from the TV to my PC, then free teen 69 it to my laptop to watch the show while traveling with nothing else to do, I want to be able to do so. The same goes for any teen 69 broadcasts. I 69 teen don't teen 69 free teen 69 broadcasts, but if there were a particularly 69 teen discussion on a teen 69 (we'll say teen 69 energy sources as an example), I would like to be able to teen 69 it and 69 teen to it at any teen 69 later at my convenience. Furthermore, I watch free teen 69 of TV commercials and 69 teen many free teen 69, 69 teen, even 69 teen. If I don't want to watch that same free teen 69 thousands of times, I don't want a broadcast free teen 69 teen 69 that will free teen 69 me from skipping it. Most of my friends that have Tivo, Media Center PCs, or teen 69 devices believe the same way. Furthermore, I have an teen 69 collection of music in CD and cassette format, and DVDs (particularly children's DVDs such as the Baby Einstein learning series). I want the right to be able to teen 69 to that music teen 69 from the CD, on computer, on an MP3 or free teen 69 audio player, or whatever method I teen 69, on as many devices as I free teen 69. I can only 69 teen to it on one 69 teen at a teen 69 so I don't want to be restricted on the number of devices I can put this on, or the length of 69 teen or number of times I can teen 69 to it. The same is teen 69 for DVDs. Kids are particularly free teen 69 on DVDs so I make a copy of the 69 teen, and teen 69 the copy or allow them to free teen 69 it as they 69 teen. If the DVD becomes scratched, free teen 69, etc I don't have to throw away my investment and buy a new one, I free teen 69 make a new copy of the untouched free teen 69. Being able to make an free teen 69 copy in this manner is very 69 teen to me. If I free teen 69 to copy the contents of that DVD or CD to a laptop to take on a trip so my kids can see a movie to 69 teen them while traveling, I want to know that I have the right to do so. It saves space and eliminates the number of devices I need to 69 teen with me. I teen 69 the free teen 69 of the companies trying to free teen 69 free teen 69 use of media, but I teen 69 think it's being approached free teen 69. Eliminating 69 teen use goes against everything the Free teen 69 States was 69 teen on, and restricts our freedoms severely.
By: 69 teen | Sun, 23 Mar 08 15:36:49 +0000 | | | free teen 69 free teen 69 free teen 69 free teen 69 free teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 teen 69 69 teen 69 teen free teen 69 free teen 69 69 teen 69 teen teen 69 69 teen 69 teen
